Comparison Study on Three Approaches for Type Synthesis of Robot Mechanisms

摘要

Basic principles and main characteristics of three approaches for structure synthesis of robot mechanisms (the screw theory-based approach, the displacement subgroup-based approach and the approach based on position and orientation characteristic (in short, POC) ) are studied and compared in this paper. The comparison deals with the mathematical tools, the symbolic representation of mechanism topological structure, the mathematical representation of POC of the output motion link with respect to the frame link, the basic equations for structure synthesis of serial and parallel mechanisms and relevant operation rules, and the characteristics of their synthesized mechanisms, etc. This comparative study shows that the POC-based approach is totally different from the other two approaches: (1) the POC-based approach requires only simple mathematical tools (such as vector algebra, set theory, etc), (2) the POC-based approach is conceptually simpler and therefore easier to understand and to use, and (3) the POC-based approach is more general.