Designing Hybrid Mobility for Agricultural Robots: Performance Analysis of Wheeled and Tracked Systems in Variable Terrain

Abstract

This study investigates the operational performance of fruit-picking robots under varying terrain slopes and soil moisture conditions, with a focus on comparing wheeled and tracked locomotion systems. A modular robot platform was designed and tested in both controlled environments and actual mountainous orchards in Shandong, China. The experiments assessed key performance metrics—average speed, slip rate, and path deviation—under combinations of four slope levels (0°, 8°, 18°, 28°) and three soil moisture levels (dry 10%, moderate 20%, wet 35%). Results reveal that wheeled robots perform optimally on dry and flat terrain but experience significant slippage and path deviation under steep and wet conditions. In contrast, tracked robots maintain better stability and terrain adaptability, demonstrating lower slip rates and more consistent trajectories across a wide range of conditions. A synergistic deterioration effect was observed when high slope and high soil moisture co-occur, significantly degrading the performance of wheeled systems, while tracked systems mitigated these effects. Complementary semi-structured interviews with 20 orchard stakeholders—including farmers, growers, and hired pickers—highlighted key user expectations: robust traction, terrain adaptability, reduced physical labor, and operational safety. The findings suggest that future agricultural robots should adopt adaptive hybrid mobility systems and integrate environmental perception capabilities to enhance performance in complex agricultural scenarios. These insights contribute practical and theoretical guidance for the design and deployment of intelligent fruit-picking robots in diverse field environments.